Toss N Sauce

Discover Toss N Sauce Pizza in Wilton, IA—serving delicious Italian favorites like manicotti, calzones, margherita, thin crust pizza, and wings. Enjoy generous portions, quick service, and a cozy atmosphere under new ownership. Call +1 563-732-9396!

Welcome to Toss N Sauce

Taste the Difference.

Toss N Sauce
Toss N Sauce
Toss N Sauce
Toss N Sauce

Nestled at 912 W 5th St, Wilton, IA, Toss N Sauce offers a hearty taste of Italy right in the heart of town. This pizza restaurant draws locals and visitors alike with its welcoming atmosphere and delicious menu, featuring a variety of pizzas, pastas, and more. With friendly service and food prepared with care, it’s a go-to for those craving authentic Italian flavors. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita or craving something adventurous like Mac-N-Cheese pizza, Toss N Sauce promises to satisfy your palate.

Many rave about the generous portion sizes and timely service, making it ideal for casual dining or a family gathering. Kick back and enjoy a slice, or two, at this local gem.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

912 W 5th St, Wilton, IA 52778, United States

Phone

+1 563-732-9396

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Toss N Sauce
Toss N Sauce
Toss N Sauce
Toss N Sauce

At Toss N Sauce, the passion for Italian food shines through every dish. This quaint restaurant features a variety of offerings, totaling 35 unique items that celebrate traditional recipes with a twist. The pizzas are undoubtedly the stars, enjoying popularity for their robust flavor and quality ingredients. Signature options, such as the Seafood Delight and Deluxe, cater to diverse tastes while ensuring everyone's craving is met. The pasta selection includes hearty choices like Chicken Parmesan and Baked Ziti, which bring comfort and satisfaction to every bite.

Toss N Sauce is more than just a dining spot; it fosters community. Locals gather here to celebrate milestones, catch up with friends, or simply enjoy a comforting meal. The inviting décor adds to the homey feel while creating a warm atmosphere—perfect for family gatherings or a laid-back dinner. Regular events, such as pizza nights and community outreach, keep the place buzzing with activity and camaraderie. Moreover, the restaurant's close-knit relationship with the local community makes it an integral part of the dining landscape in Wilton.

Its commitment to quality and service has carved a niche, ensuring that each visit is memorable.

Toss N Sauce welcomes guests with a smile, providing an experience that goes beyond just food. The staff takes pride in their work, striving to listen and accommodate special requests whenever possible. They understand that dining out should be enjoyable, an experience that lingers, not just a quick bite. For food enthusiasts, the rotating seasonal specials ensure that there’s always something new and exciting to try.

The restaurant has quickly become a popular destination, and the consistent praise from patrons affirms its status in the local culinary scene. Whether it’s a casual get-together or a special occasion, Toss N Sauce serves as a reliable source of delicious Italian cuisine.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayClosed
  • Monday11 AM-8 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Toss N Sauce boasts an extensive menu that caters to all tastes. The pizza selection, with 16 variations, includes deep dish, thin crust, and specialty pies that range from BBQ Chicken to the popular Philly. Appetizers like Cheese Stix and Six Asiago Tomatoes set the stage for a delightful meal, while fresh salads, including Chef Salads, offer healthy options. For those with a sweet tooth, the decadent Manicotti serves as both a dessert and a main dish, embodying the restaurant's commitment to Italian cuisine. The beverage list complements the menu perfectly, ensuring hydration alongside hearty meals. New owners bring fresh energy and a dedication to maintaining high standards, delighting both regulars and newcomers.

Toss N Sauce

Toss N Sauce features a cozy exterior that invites diners in. With a bright sign that beckons passersby, the restaurant stands out against the bustling backdrop of W 5th St. It’s a place that feels welcoming, whether you choose to dine indoors or enjoy warm weather on the outdoor patio. The simple outdoor seating provides the perfect spot to savor a slice while soaking up the vibrant atmosphere of Wilton. This casual vibe suits the community where locals feel at home and where laughter and conversation flow easily.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Ordered a Philly and a Deluxe pizza and they both were delicious. The Philly was awesome and I definitely recommend it. All the employees and nice and very friendly and made us feel welcome. We will definitely be stopping by on our way through Wilton for another pizza soon.

J
Jeff M.

I just finished eating here, and it's honestly one of the best local pizzas I've ever had. I couldn't stop eating it. The sauce has a nice hint of spice to it that's more appetizing than overpowering, and the toppings were all cooked nicely, as was the crust. Just a super satisfying meal all around, really delicious. Can't wait to come back for more!

A
Andrea G.

Nice place. Got a beautiful pie. It was just we were looking for. The stuffed crust is worth the extra. Enjoyed our dinner. Would recommend!

J
Joseph M.

My family and I had the taco pizza and half cheese/half pepperoni last night. Both pizzas were fantastic and priced right. We just moved to the area so we're excited that we have such a good pizza place so close to home!

K
Kaitlyn F.

Some of the best Manicotti I've ever had. Deeply looking forward to trying their other dishes. Edit: I was a bit disappointed by the Margherita. I needed to add some herbs to it myself when I took it home. The cheese, tomato and crust were phenomenal though.

c
caleb w.

The spaghetti, Alfredo, and ravioli are family favorites we have ordered multiple times. Portions are very generous. We have also enjoyed their pizza, beaver sticks and Asiago tomatoes. Delivered to New Liberty.

A
Austin B.